Two regional packaging manufacturers merged, and for the first six months they operated as one company with two completely different pricing lists. The same corrugated box design was quoted at $18.40 by plant A and at $16.90 by plant B. Customers noticed. Salespeople lost deals arguing about which division was allowed to honor whose discount, and the finance team could not calculate combined margins without building two separate spreadsheets side by side.
A Merger in Name Only
The new owner assumed the big challenge would be integrating computer systems. In reality, the biggest mess was that plant A used a $5 markup on a particular material while plant B used a $1.20 markup plus a separate handling fee. Both plants were profitable under their own rules, but now they were sharing customers and both still used different cost definitions for freight.
ERP Consulting assembled six people from purchasing, production, sales, and finance for a single working session. The goal was not to choose one price list over the other. It was to agree on exactly what went into the cost of a box, right down to whether the glue in the recipe was a shared raw material or a factory consumable charged to the customer.
The Three Decisions That Made the Price Book Work
- One cost definition. Every plant now includes freight, tooling, and a fixed overhead rate in the same way, so comparing quotes at any of the three sites feels apples to apples.
- One discount ladder. A customer who orders $200,000 a year gets the same discount no matter which plant produces the order.
- One exception log. Any price that does not fit the standard formulas is written on a shared exception sheet that gets reviewed every Friday. Nobody simply memorizes a special deal anymore.
The project took ten weeks, and less than one-third of that time involved software configuration. The hard part was getting the production teams to agree that the cost of an hour of machine time should be calculated identically at both sites. Once the cost definition was settled, everything else became an administrative task.
What the New Owner Noticed Afterward
The biggest benefit was not having a prettier price list. It was that salespeople finally argued with competitors instead of with each other, and quote response time dropped from three days to one. Margin analysis also exposed that one of the merged plants had been quoting freight charges significantly below its actual delivery cost for years.
If you are heading into any kind of merger or acquisition this year, start by printing the last ten quotes from each site and highlighting every line where the same item costs a different amount. If you circle more than three differences, what makes a shared system work is not better software reports but the uncomfortable discussions about cost and discount definitions that your leadership team has been avoiding. ERP Consulting can offer the neutral room, but the honesty has to come from inside your own team.